Sunday, November 16, 2008

e-book Readers

I have been thinking for a while about e-book readers since the time that Kindle came out. The currently available models accomplish a lot, but even with the ones on the horizon, much still seems to be desired. Here's the best comparison of various models available right now (will keep changing over time of course).

So what features do I want in a future e-book reader? (more below the fold)

Basically a fantastic tablet:
1. The size should be very slightly bigger than a letter paper, probably half and inch thick, almost like a note-pad.
2. Should have wireless internet access, and an interface like the iphone, should be able to bring up something like one-note, a touch sensitive screen.
3. A full sized keyboard should fit nicely on a letter paper in the landscape mode, and the screen should be able to recognize double handed typing.
4. All with colored e-ink, and should be able to play video as well. The refresh rate will have to improve considerably for this to happen. The OLEDs can already do this, so e-ink should not be too far behind.
5. Of course, mp3 player, GPS etc are a given, but probably not too large a hard-drive (solid state).

So let's see how much of this is available in the existing models.

The Iliad I-Rex comes close, as you can see in the following video. Dimensions are slightly smaller, but will do. Refresh rate is a real problem, and the internet browsing needs a clunky hack.


Jinke, the Chinese company making the less flashy Hanlin e-book reader had announced the V9 which would be the perfect size, but since then they have withdrawn it from the website, so probably not happening. I might have read somewhere that the company which makes the e-ink screens canceled, couldn't keep up with the order flow.



6 comments:

Dyutiman Das said...

According to Wired magazine Amazon Kindle 2.0 will be released on Feb 9th.

But the upcoming Plastic Logic looks fantastic and a possible Kindle killer. The best idea is if Bezos buys the company and then we can get the EV-DO on it. More video here

veysey said...

Plastic logic looks sweet indeed. Kindle I is supposed to be good, but ...

I don't go for the subscription model. Part of the fun of books is that you OWN it, don't have to pay for it, etc. I don't want to have another monthly expense to keep track of ... and it adds up, too.

Wonder if Plastic Logic will follow that approach?

Dyutiman Das said...

this link would seem to imply that they plan to have an online bookstore, rather than subscription. Where did you hear about that? Kindle is purchase right? Kapil now has a Kindle, but he won't show it to me.

Dyutiman Das said...

Amazon is out with kindle 2.0 , to be sold from Feb 24. Tomorrow I plan to post pictures from the Plastic Logic booth at the O'Reilly exhibition at the Mariott Marquis.

Features of new Kindle:
Plus:
1. 20% faster refresh rate.
2. more color definition of screen
3. thinner and lighter.
4. read-aloud feature like pdf,
5. USB charger.

Minus:
1. larger in size with same screen size,
2. No SD slot, battery not removable.
3. Cover is extra $30.
4. Personally I think the new design is far worse than the original one, I liked the angular shape.

Dyutiman Das said...

Here's my first look at Plastic Logic, click on the picture for higher resolution.

Also here's a blog for using Kindle as a browser.

veysey said...

Hey dude -

Hope you had a good time across the pond. Did you see that sony announced two new readers? PRS-600 and ... ? due out the end of the month.

Small form factor, but they lowered the price point, and one of them supports stylus annotations. Of course, neither supports the web, etc like you want.

Plastic logic looks like it will materialize at the beginning of next year.

Have you looked at all into the maze of ebook formats?

I'm trying to decipher them and determine how to convert. Can't stand vendor lock-in.

epub looks good. Sony also annouced that they're distributing a bunch (1,000,000) of google-scanned public domain books in epub format.

Finally, calibre looks to be a very good (and open) piece of ebook software. I think it can convert everything except Sony's LRF format.

Talk to you soon ...